Various wine critics use various points systems
to score wine. They range from mathematically
based methods such as the 20 point systems adopted
by UK wine critic Jancis Robinson and famous wine
retailers Berry Bros. & Rudd to the less formal
scale advocated by Hugh Johnson which rates wine
according to how much of it you would like drink
– the spectrum running from ‘one sip’
to ‘the entire vineyard’ !
I have decided to follow the 100 point system
of Robert Parker [www.erobertparker.com], the
famous wine Critic from America.
There are arguments for and against all of
the rating systems. Some dispute the accuracy
of the 100 points system, while others maintain
that it is very difficult to differentiate scores
on the small scale systems such as the 20 points/5
stars system.
Mindful of its failings, I feel the 100 point
system allows me give you with most objective
score and communicate the quality of the wines
I’m tasting so that you can make the most
informed decision about your purchases.
The following is a rough breakdown of the how
the 100 points are allocated:-
50 Points – All wine considered receives
a score of at least 50 points
5 Points – For the colour and appearance
of the wine.
15 points – For Aroma and Bouquet.
20 Points – For Flavour and Finish
10 Points – For the overall quality or
potential of the wine.
It is important to note though that just because
a wine only scores 86 points this does not mean
that this is a bad wine – quite the contrary.
Wines scoring over 80 points are above average
to very good [89 points]. I will generally breakdown
wines into the following brackets:-
96 – 100 points represents an Extraordinary
Wine
90 – 95 points represents an outstanding
wine
80 – 89 Points represents barely above
average
70 – 79 Points represents an average
wine
60 – 69 Points represents a below average
wine.
50 – 59 Points represents an unacceptable
wine.
By contrast, and so as to ensure the greatest
objectivity across www.robertfranciswine.ie,
“The Cru” will use a small scale
point system when reviewing their wines [5 Star
scoring system]. Through this measure I am hoping
to ensure that you benefit from the best of
both scoring systems.